gender identity discrimination

Should I Sue My Employer?

Should I sue my employer?  Maybe. Speaking in very general terms, there are three major categories of laws protecting employees. These categories are: (1) discrimination law, (2) leave law, and (3) wage payment law. Below is a very brief discussion of each:

  1. Discrimination: Discrimination against individuals on the basis of their membership in a protected class is illegal. Protected classes include: gender, race, disability, age, national origin, religion and others. It is unlawful for an employer to discriminate against an employee based on their protected status. The discrimination can be failure to hire, decisions related to pay, discipline and decisions to terminate employment. The principle is that you cannot be treated differently than similarly situated employees on the basis of your protected status.
  2. Leave: Certain employees are entitled to leave by state and/or federal law. If you are entitled to leave, it is illegal for your employer to interfere with your leave, or retaliate against you for taking leave.
  3. Wages: There are also many wage payment laws which govern how your employer must pay your wages. These laws relate to payment of overtime lawful deductions from wages, and what constitutes “work” such that you have to be compensated.

If you are having issues with your employer, you should speak to an employment lawyer. You may have a viable lawsuit against your employer, and a good employment lawyer can help guide you in reviewing your situation.

should I sue my employer?
should I sue my employer?

Some Things to Think About If Your Employment is Terminated

What should I do if I get fired? Here some things to think about if your employment is terminated:

  • Were you offered severance agreement?  If so, make sure an attorney reviews the severance agreement.  You will be giving up rights, and may be agreeing to take less than you are entitled to or worth.
  • For example, if you have a pension, your severance agreement may be releasing your rights under ERISA, the federal law governing pensions. Make sure you are not accidentally giving up your pension rights. If you had an employer-matched 401 and are not vested, you are probably giving up the employer contribution to your 401.
  • Did you have a non-compete agreement?  If so, it could limit your ability to get a new job.  If not, your employer may include one (as part of your severance agreement), which may limit your ability to get a new job. If the time restriction is longer than the number of weeks of severance, it is probably not worth signing the agreement unless you are going into an entirely new field.
  • If you did sign a non-compete agreement prior to starting your job or during the course of your employment, you should also have an attorney review it for you to make sure you understand your limitations before you sign a severance agreement.  You will most likely be reaffirming those restrictions in a severance agreement, so may be giving up your defenses to the non-competition provisions.  Some employers will try to add restrictions you did not have, make the restrictions longer or for a larger geographic area.  Some know that they had an agreement that was not enforceable and use the severance agreement to put in place an enforceable provision.
  • Is the release mutual?  If the employer wants you to release them from any claims, they should also release you.  Some employers require employees to sign releases and then turn around and sue the former employee for alleged wrongdoing on the job.  Mutual releases assure that any claims are released by both sides.  In banking or other financial arenas, the employer will want an exception for undiscovered financial fraud/embezzlement, which should be acceptable.  But if they know about it at the time of the agreement, they should be willing to release it or give up their right to a release so the employee can assert any defenses or counterclaims he or she might have.
  • Is confidentiality mutual?  Employers want the severance agreement to be kept confidential.  But if the employer does not have to keep it confidential, they may get cute and say things to references like, “I have to look at the agreement to see what I’m allowed to say.”  Protect yourself and make sure that they can’t disclose the existence of the agreement to potential employers.
  • Include non-disparagement provisions.  You don’t want your employer to be able to say bad things to potential employers or to customers, co-workers or others in the community.  They will likely want the non-disparagement to be mutual, to keep you from bad-mouthing them, which is acceptable.  It is worth the peace of mind to know that they will not be making negative comments that keep you from future employment.
  • Do you have health insurance?  Many employers will pay some or all of your COBRA payments to tide you over while you are working.  You need to make sure you understand what will happen to your insurance benefits upon termination.
  • Do you have stock options, stock appreciation rights, or other similar rights?  Make sure the agreement is not making you give up valuable rights you may have.  If you were fired to keep you from vesting, you may have claims against the employer.
  • Do you have any potential claims against the employer?  Potential claims may give you leverage to negotiate a severance package if it is not offered, or to negotiate a better package.  Ask yourself some questions:
    • Am I of a different race, age, sex, national origin, marital status, color, or religion from those who were not terminated for the same reason or offense?  If so, you may have a discrimination claim.
    • Was I recently sexually harassed or the victim of other discriminatory harassment based upon race, age, religion, national origin, marital status, color, or disability?  You can’t be fired in retaliation for reporting such harassment.
    • Did I recently report, object to, or refuse to participate in discrimination, harassment, or illegal activity?  If so, you may be a whistleblower.
    • Did I recently make a worker’s compensation claim?  If so, it’s illegal to terminate you for making such a claim, and you also need to make sure you are not giving up your worker’s compensation claim in the agreement.
    • Did I recently take leave due to bereavement, sickness, disability, or serious medical condition of a family member?  If so, you may have a Family and Medical Leave Act claim.
    • Does the employer owe me overtime or wages?  Make sure you are paid what you are owed.  Plus, failure to pay wages is a great defense to a non-compete agreement.
    • Did I recently testify against the employer or in any court case where I was subpoenaed?  You can’t be terminated for your testimony under subpoena.
    • Am I pregnant?  You can’t be terminated for your pregnancy, or because you recently gave birth and the employer has stereotypical beliefs about women with children.
    • Did the employer breach a contract with me?
    • Am I over 40?  If so, in a layoff or redundancy, the employer is supposed to provide you with a list of the ages of the others laid off or made redundant so you can determine whether or not age discrimination has occurred.

If you are in doubt about your rights or any potential claims you may have, contact an attorney at our firm to discuss your options.  Someone will get back to you within 24 hours.

 

Transgender Discrimination Law in New York City

Transgender Discrimination is illegal in New York City. Under the New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”), transgender individuals are protected against workplace discrimination.   The NYCHRL explicitly states that no one can be discriminated against on the basis of gender.  The law then defines gender as "a person's gender identity, self-image, appearance, behavior or expression, whether or not that gender identity, self-image, appearance, behavior or expression is different from that traditionally associated with the legal sex assigned to that person at birth."   Thus, transgender individuals are entitled to the same workplace rights as all other individuals in New York City. If you feel that you have been a victim of transgender discrimination, or any discrimination based upon your gender, sexual orientation, race, disability, age, etc., please contact us. Similarly, if you were terminated shortly after you made an honest complaint of discrimination, you may be a victim of unlawful retaliation. Whether you have been victimized by transgender discrimination, or any other form of discrimination, we can help you fight back. One of our experienced Labor and Employment attorneys will get back to you withing 24 hours. Initial consultations are free, and we handle most cases on a contingency basis - we do not get paid unless we recover for you.

EEOC Rules Transgender Status Protected from Discrimination Under Title VII

Employment Discrimination on the basis of gender includes discrimination on the basis of gender identity and transgender status.  If you believe you are the victim of employment discrimination on the basis of your gender or gender identity, our New York employment discrimination attorneys can help you fight for your rights. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) recently determined that discrimination based on gender identity, change of sex or transgender status constitutes sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

Mia Macy claimed that she was denied a job at the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives when she announced that she would be transitioning her gender from male to female.  Macy applied for the job as a man and was told that she would get the job pending a background check, but was informed the position was no longer available after stating that she would be undergoing a sex change operation.

Believing she had been unlawfully denied the position, Macy filed a charge with the EEOC.  The EEOC determined that claims of discrimination based on transgender status, also referred to as claims based on gender identity, are cognizable under Title VII.  The EEOC explained that Title VII's protections encompass a person’s biological sex, as well as their gender, which includes cultural and social aspects associated with masculinity and femininity.

In making its determination, the EEOC relied on U.S. Supreme Court precedent holding that Title VII forbids employers from penalizing employees who fail to conform to stereotypical norms.  Under that precedent, Macy would have been discriminated against if she was denied a position due to the perception that her transgender status did not conform to gender stereotypes.

A copy of the decision is here:  https://www.pcc.edu/programs/paralegal/documents/macy-v-holder.pdf

If you believe you have been a victim of employment discrimination on the basis of your gender or gender identity, please contact one of our New York employment discrimination attorneys.